More Appellate Practice news More news in Wisconsin Find Appellate Practice lawyers in Wisconsin
In a groundbreaking decision that could have far-reaching implications for future cases, the Wisconsin Appellate Court ruled on October 23, 2025, to set a new precedent on jury instructions in criminal trials.The case in question involved a defendant who had been convicted of burglary and theft, but who argued on appeal that the jury had been improperly instructed on the elements of the crimes. The defendant's attorney pointed to several errors in the jury instructions that they argued had led to an unfair trial.In a 3-2 decision, the Appellate Court sided with the defendant, holding that the jury instructions given at trial were indeed flawed and had likely prejudiced the outcome of the case. The Court pointed to specific language in the instructions that had the potential to confuse jurors and mislead them on the elements of the crimes in question.The ruling is significant not only for the defendant in this particular case but also for the legal community at large. Appellate courts in Wisconsin often look to precedent when deciding similar cases in the future, so this decision will likely have a ripple effect on how jury instructions are given in criminal trials going forward."We believe that this ruling will help ensure that defendants receive fair trials and that the jury fully understands the elements of the crimes they are asked to consider," said Chief Judge Lisa Johnson, who authored the majority opinion.The dissenting judges, however, expressed concern that the decision could set a dangerous precedent and lead to an increase in appeals based on technicalities in jury instructions. They argued that the error in this case was minor and did not significantly impact the outcome of the trial.Despite the dissenting opinion, legal experts are hailing the decision as a step forward in ensuring fairness and accuracy in the criminal justice system. The case is expected to be closely studied and cited in future appellate practice cases in Wisconsin and beyond.