More Constitutional Law news More news in Montana Find Constitutional Law lawyers in Montana
In a groundbreaking decision, the Montana Supreme Court announced their rulings on several key constitutional law cases that have been making headlines across the state. The rulings, handed down on September 13, 2025, have the potential to have a lasting impact on the legal landscape in Montana for years to come.One of the most closely watched cases was that of Smith v. Montana Department of Revenue, in which the court was asked to decide whether a tax on out-of-state online retailers violated the commerce clause of the United States Constitution. The court, in a unanimous decision, ruled that the tax did indeed violate the commerce clause and struck it down. This decision is expected to have far-reaching implications for how states can tax online sales in the future.In another important case, Daniels v. Montana Department of Health, the court addressed the constitutionality of a law requiring parental consent for minors seeking abortions. The court, in a closely divided decision, upheld the law, stating that it did not unconstitutionally burden a minor's right to choose. The decision has sparked heated debate across the state, with advocacy groups on both sides of the issue vowing to continue fighting for their respective positions.In a further blow to the state government, the court also ruled in favor of the plaintiffs in Thompson v. State of Montana, a case challenging the constitutionality of the state's campaign finance laws. The court found that the laws unduly restricted the plaintiffs' right to political speech and association, and struck them down as unconstitutional. This decision is expected to have a significant impact on how political campaigns are run in Montana going forward.Overall, the rulings handed down by the Montana Supreme Court on September 13, 2025, represent a significant shift in the state's constitutional law landscape. With decisions that will impact everything from online sales to reproductive rights to campaign finance, the court has set the stage for years of legal battles and policy debates to come. It remains to be seen how these rulings will shape the future of Montana law and politics.